free consultation (618) 693-2462
Free Consultation

Immunotherapy vs. Chemotherapy for Mesothelioma

November 8, 2024

Mesothelioma is a rare and aggressive form of cancer that primarily affects the lining of the lungs (pleura), but it can also develop in the lining of the abdomen (peritoneum), heart (pericardium), or testicles (tunica vaginalis). The primary cause of mesothelioma is exposure to asbestos, a naturally occurring fibrous mineral that was commonly used in construction, shipbuilding, and various industrial applications throughout the 20th century. When asbestos fibers are inhaled or ingested, they can become lodged in the body’s tissues, causing inflammation and, over time, leading to cancer development.

This type of cancer is particularly challenging because its symptoms often appear decades after asbestos exposure, making early detection difficult. By the time mesothelioma is diagnosed, it is usually in an advanced stage, which complicates treatment and negatively impacts survival rates. Common symptoms include shortness of breath, chest pain, persistent coughing, and weight loss, though these signs are often mistaken for less severe conditions, delaying diagnosis further.

Importance of Understanding Treatment Options for Mesothelioma Patients

Given the aggressive nature of mesothelioma and the late stage at which it is frequently diagnosed, understanding the available treatment options is critical for patients and their families. Mesothelioma has historically been difficult to treat, and its prognosis is often poor. However, advancements in medical research, particularly in the fields of chemotherapy and immunotherapy, are providing new hope for patients.

Chemotherapy, long considered the standard treatment for mesothelioma, has been effective in slowing the progression of the disease, but it often comes with significant side effects and does not always lead to long-term survival. More recently, immunotherapy, which harnesses the body’s immune system to fight cancer, has emerged as a promising alternative or complementary option. As both treatments have different mechanisms and impacts on the body, it’s vital for patients to explore their options thoroughly, considering factors such as the stage of their disease, their overall health, and their personal preferences.

Understanding these treatments allows mesothelioma patients to make informed decisions about their care, potentially improving their quality of life and extending survival. With the right combination of therapies, patients can better manage the disease, reduce symptoms, and maintain hope for improved outcomes.

Effectiveness

Chemotherapy and immunotherapy show more promising results for different stages of mesothelioma.

Chemotherapy

This has been the standard treatment for mesothelioma for many years and is often used as a first-line therapy, especially for patients in the early or middle stages of the disease. In these cases, chemotherapy can help shrink tumors, slow the spread of the cancer, and provide symptom relief. For early-stage mesothelioma, chemotherapy combined with surgery can improve overall outcomes, offering a temporary but significant reduction in tumor size and progression. However, the results are often short-term, and many patients experience a recurrence of the disease within months.

Immunotherapy

This is a newer treatment option, showing more promising results for patients in advanced stages of mesothelioma who may no longer be candidates for surgery or traditional chemotherapy. Immunotherapy’s success is most notable in patients with higher PD-L1 expression, as checkpoint inhibitors have shown better effectiveness in these cases. For some patients, immunotherapy has led to longer-term tumor control and, in rare cases, remission. While not all patients respond to immunotherapy, those who do can experience more durable and lasting benefits compared to chemotherapy alone.

Side Effects

The side effects of each treatment are different in severity and duration.

Chemotherapy

Chemotherapy’s side effects are often more severe and affect a wider range of the body’s systems. Common side effects include nausea, vomiting, fatigue, hair loss, anemia, and immune suppression, which can last for several months during and after treatment. Chemotherapy’s impact on healthy cells, particularly those that divide rapidly (like those in the hair, blood, and digestive system), leads to more widespread damage and a greater disruption to the patient’s overall quality of life. The effects of chemotherapy can be particularly draining and long-lasting, requiring careful management to avoid secondary complications like infections.

Immunotherapy

Immunotherapy generally has fewer and less severe side effects compared to chemotherapy. Its side effects are mostly immune-related, such as skin rash, fatigue, and inflammation in certain organs (lungs, liver, or bowels). These side effects tend to be more manageable, and in many cases, they can be treated with corticosteroids or immunosuppressive drugs. However, in rare cases, immunotherapy can cause severe immune responses that may require hospitalization. Overall, patients undergoing immunotherapy often experience fewer disruptions to their daily lives compared to those receiving chemotherapy, with side effects typically resolving more quickly.

Patient Suitability

Factors that may make a patient more suited for chemotherapy vs. immunotherapy include:

Chemotherapy

Chemotherapy is often best suited for patients with early to mid-stage mesothelioma or those who are strong candidates for a multimodal approach (chemotherapy combined with surgery and/or radiation). Chemotherapy may be the preferred option for patients who have a higher tumor burden or need rapid symptom relief. However, it may not be suitable for elderly patients or those with underlying health conditions that would make it difficult for them to tolerate the harsh side effects.

Immunotherapy

Immunotherapy is typically better suited for patients with advanced-stage mesothelioma, especially those who have not responded well to chemotherapy or are not candidates for surgery. It may also be more appropriate for younger patients or those with stronger immune systems, as immunotherapy works by stimulating immune responses. Additionally, patients with higher PD-L1 expression in their tumors are more likely to benefit from immunotherapy. In cases where patients have other underlying conditions that would make chemotherapy too taxing, immunotherapy may provide a more tolerable option.

Long-Term Survival Rates

Each therapy affects survival and remission rates slightly differently.

Chemotherapy

While chemotherapy can extend survival for mesothelioma patients, particularly when used in combination with surgery, its impact on long-term survival is often limited. The median survival for mesothelioma patients undergoing chemotherapy is typically around 12 to 18 months, with some patients experiencing a longer period of stable disease. However, chemotherapy rarely leads to long-term remission, and many patients face a recurrence of the disease within a year.

Immunotherapy

Immunotherapy has shown potential for extending survival beyond what is possible with chemotherapy alone. While not all patients respond to immunotherapy, those who do may experience significantly longer periods of tumor control, with some patients living beyond two years or more. In rare cases, immunotherapy has led to long-term remission, offering hope for sustained cancer control. Immunotherapy’s ability to stimulate the immune system for ongoing cancer surveillance may provide a more durable response than chemotherapy, though long-term survival rates still vary.

Take the Next Steps Today

Given the complexity of mesothelioma and the variety of treatment options available, it’s essential for patients to consult with their healthcare providers to create a treatment plan that is tailored to their unique needs. Oncologists and specialists can guide patients through the benefits and risks of each therapy, recommend genetic testing to identify personalized treatment options, and help manage side effects.

If you or a loved one has been diagnosed with mesothelioma, it’s crucial to explore all your treatment options and understand your legal rights. At Bailey Glasser, our experienced team is here to help. Call us today at (866) 871-7971 or fill out our online form for a free consultation. We’re ready to provide the guidance and support you need to navigate this challenging time. Don’t wait – reach out to us now to get started on your path to the best possible outcome.